I did not like this product, I felt the finished line looked too fake.I ordered this to try and it is indeed waterproof. Very easy shading and it does not look harsh or overdrawn when filling in sparse areas or lengthening the tail. Having said that, tiny precise hair strokes are not possible, even with the smaller tear-drop shape, because as soon as you use it once it rounds the edge. I recently discovered my old grey brown Etude pencil (the one that's not waterproof, with the old spoolie) and fell back in love with it. Had previously been using the Fenty black brown (for the size of the hair stroke) but found Fenty created too harsh brows. This is a dupe for Fenty's spoolie brush. If you like that teeny paddle brush and the grey brown color, this will be the perfect combo! Highly recommend if you're looking for some natural shading. It doesn't budge! Also, one pencil, with daily use, lasts me 2+ months easily! A ton of product (vs. other reviews).Tried this because of the brand. However, i find it too light that I have to apply several times back and forth to get desired look. After a few hours, my pictures still look like I didn’t apply eyebrows on.I've had this 3 months already and use it almost every day and still haven't run out. Granted, I use it to touch up and fill in, I don't darkly draw my brow on with this or anything. I really like this pencil because it gives a very soft, natural look and the angle of the pencil makes it easy to mimic strokes of hair for a natural fill. Plus, the brush that comes with it is is a great texture--not too soft or hard. It lasts a long time on, too. If I didn't wash my face I could wear it the next day little or no touch up. I will be ordering this again for sure, I've found the perfect brow pencil for me.I finally found a eye product that I simply love. This product is just as described and in hard to find grey. I recommend highly.This brand is awesomeThis blends nicely with my light brownish-greying hair. I've tried dozens of colors, crayons, pens, etc. - this is the best so far. Even my husband has commented "your eyebrows look great - natural!" When a man notices your eyebrows, two things: the old ones were bad, the new ones must be good.I threw it away because of the brush end. Otherwise it was fine.This is a good product and I like the brush on the end.